Skip to main content

Sherwood Forest Homes for Sale in Maggie Valley, SC

Sherwood Forest in Maggie Valley feels like a tucked-away mountain enclave where wooded lots, paved access, and cabin-style homes set a distinctly Western North Carolina tone.

Active
3
Recently Sold
42

Active & Pending Listings

About Sherwood Forest

Community overview based on MLS listing data for Sherwood Forest, Maggie Valley

First Impressions

Sherwood Forest in Maggie Valley feels like a tucked-away mountain enclave where wooded lots, paved access, and cabin-style homes set a distinctly Western North Carolina tone. The setting is elevated and leafy, with creek sounds, mountain air, and generous outdoor living spaces shaping the everyday experience. Many homes here lean into porches, decks, fireplaces, and flexible lower levels, creating a relaxed retreat feel that still works for full-time living.

"Wooded mountain homes here pair easy access with the kind of porch-and-firepit lifestyle people come to Maggie Valley for."

Home Styles & Community Feel

This is a single-family neighborhood with a strong cabin and mountain-home identity. Homes commonly date from the late 1970s through the 2010s, and the mix includes log cabins, contemporary mountain homes, and updated retreats with finished basements, garages, and workshop space. Stone fireplaces, vaulted ceilings, open layouts, and wraparound or covered decks appear often, while many properties also bring practical updates such as metal roofs, newer windows, and refreshed kitchens. Lot sizes are comfortable for the setting, with a wooded backdrop that gives the community a more secluded, established feel without losing convenience.

Sherwood Forest also has a clear short-term-rental presence, and several homes are described as turnkey, furnished, or well suited to vacation use. That gives the neighborhood a lively second-home character while still supporting year-round occupancy.

Amenities & Daily Rhythm

Daily life here tends to center on outdoor spaces and mountain views. Fire pits, screened porches, hot tubs, and decks are common themes, and the nearby creek or stream element adds to the setting in a subtle but memorable way. A number of homes include basements, lower-level living rooms, bonus rooms, or attached garages, which makes the floor plans feel adaptable rather than purely rustic. Roads are described as paved or mostly paved, and several remarks emphasize easy year-round access.

"It’s a neighborhood built for porch mornings, mountain evenings, and flexible spaces that adapt to how you live."

Location & Schools

Sherwood Forest sits in Maggie Valley, just off the main village area and close to downtown Maggie Valley, with some listings noting it is within about half a mile or just minutes away. From here, residents also describe an easy drive to Waynesville, Cherokee, Asheville, the Blue Ridge Parkway, and the Great Smoky Mountains. Shopping, restaurants, hiking, and skiing are all part of the local routine, and the community’s mountain-road setting keeps those destinations within practical reach. School assignments commonly point to Jonathan Valley Elementary, Waynesville Middle, and Tuscola High, placing the neighborhood within the broader Haywood County school pattern.

Questions about Sherwood Forest?

Palmetto Park Realty Team · Maggie Valley

Ask about Sherwood Forest — we answer fast

Own a home in Sherwood Forest?

See what it's worth — your home's own sale history plus recent Sherwood Forest sales, free.

What's my home worth?

Nearby Communities

Communities similar to Sherwood Forest

Recently Sold in Sherwood Forest 42 recently sold in Sherwood Forest, Maggie Valley with dates and property details

Recently Sold

42 recently sold in Sherwood Forest, Maggie Valley

Property Sold Sold Price Days on Market Size Sold to Ask Sold $/SF
196 Friar Tuck Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 196 Friar Tuck Lane 2 bd · 2 ba Jun 18 2026 $390,000 47 1,731 sq ft 96.3% $225
282 Friar Tuck Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 282 Friar Tuck Lane 2 bd · 2 ba Mar 27 2026 $250,000 401 960 sq ft 93.6% $260
95 Robin Hood Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 95 Robin Hood Lane 2 bd · 2 ba Dec 15 2025 $345,900 129 1,000 sq ft 98.9% $346
44 Robin Hood Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 44 Robin Hood Lane 2 bd · 2 ba Jul 22 2025 $317,800 117 1,028 sq ft 97.8% $309
307 Nottingham Road sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 307 Nottingham Road 3 bd · 3 ba Jul 7 2025 $500,000 40 2,481 sq ft 95.1% $202
249 Nottingham Road sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 249 Nottingham Road 2 bd · 2 ba Nov 17 2023 $490,000 190 1,946 sq ft 98.0% $252
56 Friar Tuck Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 56 Friar Tuck Lane 2 bd · 2 ba Nov 16 2023 $315,000 66 1,331 sq ft 96.9% $237
309 Nottingham Road sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 309 Nottingham Road Nov 3 2023 $34,900 99 100.0%
170 Nottingham Road sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 170 Nottingham Road 2 bd · 2 ba Jun 23 2023 $363,500 91 1,780 sq ft 98.5% $204
30 Friar Tuck Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 30 Friar Tuck Lane 3 bd · 2 ba Jun 16 2023 $402,000 84 2,247 sq ft 94.6% $179
29 Robin Hood Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 29 Robin Hood Lane 3 bd · 2 ba Apr 24 2023 $285,750 34 1,205 sq ft 103.9% $237
204 Nottingham Road sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 204 Nottingham Road 3 bd · 2 ba Jan 12 2023 $410,000 238 2,316 sq ft 91.1% $177
233 Nottingham Road sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 233 Nottingham Road 3 bd · 2 ba Aug 25 2022 $310,000 136 1,380 sq ft 82.7% $225
165 Nottingham Road sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 165 Nottingham Road 2 bd · 1 ba Jan 20 2022 $221,000 209 933 sq ft 96.1% $237
170 Nottingham Road sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 170 Nottingham Road 3 bd · 2 ba Dec 17 2021 $310,000 57 1,800 sq ft 96.9% $172
249 Nottingham Road sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 249 Nottingham Road 2 bd · 2 ba Nov 30 2021 $375,000 92 2,130 sq ft 100.0% $176
307 Nottingham Road sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 307 Nottingham Road 3 bd · 3 ba Jul 26 2021 $364,000 84 2,630 sq ft 96.0% $138
309 Nottingham Road sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 309 Nottingham Road Jun 7 2021 $19,000 18 71.7%
139 Friar Tuck Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 139 Friar Tuck Lane 3 bd · 3 ba Dec 9 2020 $342,000 91 2,400 sq ft 98.0% $143
26 Marion Drive sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 26 Marion Drive 3 bd · 3 ba Nov 13 2020 $348,000 70 1,743 sq ft 99.4% $200
38 Robin Hood Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 38 Robin Hood Lane 3 bd · 3 ba Nov 12 2020 $316,500 45 2,020 sq ft 93.1% $157
38 Robin Hood Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 38 Robin Hood Lane 2 bd · 2 ba Dec 23 2019 $210,000 30 1,270 sq ft 100.0% $165
268 Nottingham Road sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 268 Nottingham Road 3 bd · 2 ba Jul 11 2019 $175,000 93 1,752 sq ft 94.6% $100
249 Nottingham Road 10 sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 249 Nottingham Road 10 2 bd · 2 ba Apr 15 2019 $185,000 158 1,815 sq ft 92.5% $102
232 Friar Tuck Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 232 Friar Tuck Lane 2 bd · 2 ba Apr 4 2019 $239,900 39 1,602 sq ft 100.0% $150
38 Robinhood Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 38 Robinhood Lane 2 bd · 2 ba May 9 2018 $190,000 384 1,270 sq ft 97.4% $150
282 Friar Tuck Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 282 Friar Tuck Lane 2 bd · 2 ba Aug 24 2017 $139,700 168 968 sq ft 93.1% $144
232 Friar Tuck Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 232 Friar Tuck Lane 2 bd · 2 ba Jul 20 2017 $211,000 53 1,580 sq ft 96.3% $134
42 Robinhood Lane 42 & 43 sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 42 Robinhood Lane 42 & 43 Mar 29 2017 $22,500 390 86.5%
196 Friar Tuck Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 196 Friar Tuck Lane 2 bd · 2 ba Mar 27 2017 $175,000 485 1,708 sq ft 97.3% $102
307 Nottingham Road sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 307 Nottingham Road 4 bd · 3 ba Jan 13 2017 $180,000 165 2,683 sq ft 90.0% $67
44 Robinhood Lane 33 sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 44 Robinhood Lane 33 2 bd · 2 ba Nov 1 2016 $155,000 66 1,007 sq ft 100.0% $154
268 Nottingham Road sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 268 Nottingham Road 3 bd · 2 ba Apr 25 2016 $120,000 289 1,728 sq ft 85.7% $69
150 Friar Tuck sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 150 Friar Tuck 2 bd · 2 ba Dec 3 2015 $174,000 182 1,875 sq ft 97.2% $93
234 Nottingham Rd sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 234 Nottingham Rd 3 bd · 2 ba Sep 8 2015 $224,900 161 2,253 sq ft 97.8% $100
232 Friar Tuck Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 232 Friar Tuck Lane 2 bd · 2 ba Jul 7 2015 $185,000 105 1,614 sq ft 94.9% $115
282 Friar Tuck Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 282 Friar Tuck Lane 2 bd · 2 ba Dec 31 2014 $93,000 148 968 sq ft 93.1% $96
203 201 Nottingham Road sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 203 201 Nottingham Road 2 bd · 2 ba Nov 10 2014 $125,000 39 1,513 sq ft 100.0% $83
196 Friar Tuck Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 196 Friar Tuck Lane 2 bd · 2 ba May 21 2014 $135,000 132 1,700 sq ft 96.5% $79
234 Nottingham Drive sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 234 Nottingham Drive 3 bd · 2 ba Jul 19 2013 $205,000 474 2,254 sq ft 82.1% $91
305 Nottingham Road sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 305 Nottingham Road 4 bd · 4 ba Nov 30 2012 $250,000 421 3,200 sq ft 78.1% $78
30 Friar Tuck Lane sold home in Maggie Valley, SC 30 Friar Tuck Lane 3 bd · 2 ba Sep 20 2012 $148,900 310 2,037 sq ft 99.3% $73

Market Trends

Closed sales from MLS history for Sherwood Forest, Maggie Valley

Median sale price · trailing 12 mo
$345,900
5 sales closed · Jul 2025 – Jun 2026
3 yr ▾ 4.8% Maggie Valley 1 yr ▾ 4.7%

Sherwood Forest median sale price is $345,900; Maggie Valley is down 4.7%.

+1 outside price range.

$300k $400k $500k 20222023202420252026 $346k Sherwood Forest$351k Maggie Valley Sales closed per quarter peak 3

The Sherwood Forest real estate market shows buyer's market conditions. Homes typically sell within 111 days. With 2 active listings and 3 homes sold in the past year, buyers have more negotiating power and time to decide.

Pricing

Median Price
$479,500
Average Price
$479,500
$/Sq.Ft (Q1)
$100
1-Yr Price Trend
−15.4%

Property Details

Avg Bedrooms
2.5
Avg Bathrooms
2.2
Avg Lot Size
0.52 acres

Market Activity

Active Listings
2
Sold Last Year
3
Median Days to Sell
111 days

Community Info

Median Year Built
1983
New Construction
2%

Recently Off Market Properties

Listings taken off the market in the past year in Sherwood Forest, Maggie Valley

1 property
Looking for similar properties?

These homes are no longer available, but they show recent pricing and listing activity in Sherwood Forest. Our agents can help you watch for new listings in this area.

Contact an agent
Call Map

Add a place

Listing alerts

Save this search

Choose a name and how often you want new-match alerts.

You can remove alerts any time from Saved searches.