$675,000 $182/sqft
200 Pumkin Patch Road
Rutherfordton, NC 28139
3 bd · 3 ba · 3,701 sqft · 2005 · 2 mo ago
Gilbertown in Rutherfordton has the feel of an established foothills address where larger lots, mature trees, and custom-built homes create a distinctly spacious setting.
Listing summary: 2 Active35 Recently Sold
$675,000 $182/sqft
Rutherfordton, NC 28139
3 bd · 3 ba · 3,701 sqft · 2005 · 2 mo ago
$725,000 $172/sqft
Rutherfordton, NC 28139
5 bd · 5 ba · 4,204 sqft · 2000 · 5 mo ago
$559,900 $154/sqft
Rutherfordton, NC 28139
5 bd · 4 ba · 3,640 sqft · 2006 · DOM: 39 d
$319,900 $151/sqft
Rutherfordton, NC 28139
4 bd · 2 ba · 2,116 sqft · 2001 · DOM: 33 d
$37,900
Rutherfordton, NC 28139
DOM: 248 d
$599,900 $149/sqft
Rutherfordton, NC 28139
3 bd · 3 ba · 4,022 sqft · 2006 · DOM: 232 d
Trails
Rails to Trails · Thermal Belt Rail Trail
Medical
Rutherford Regional Medical Center
Transportation
Rutherford County Airport · Hwy 221 · Hwy 64 +1
$62,000
Rutherfordton, NC 28139
DOM: 314 d
$20,000
Rutherfordton, NC 28139
DOM: 308 d
$1,200,000 $168/sqft
Rutherfordton, NC 28139
4 bd · 5 ba · 7,163 sqft · 2001 · DOM: 275 d
$675,000 $186/sqft
Rutherfordton, NC 28139
4 bd · 5 ba · 3,637 sqft · 2007 · DOM: 74 d
$45,000
Rutherfordton, NC 28139
3.3 ac · DOM: 284 d
$324,900 $169/sqft
Rutherfordton, NC 28139
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,921 sqft · 1997 · DOM: 144 d
Foothills region, western North Carolina
AI-assisted overview based on MLS listing data for Gilbertown, Rutherfordton
Gilbertown in Rutherfordton has the feel of an established foothills address where larger lots, mature trees, and custom-built homes create a distinctly spacious setting. The neighborhood’s setting leans rural without feeling remote, and many properties are tucked onto generous acreage that gives each home room to breathe. Recent listings show a mix of substantial residences, workshops, decks, and finished lower levels, reinforcing the sense that this is a place where homes are designed to be used fully, inside and out.
"Spacious lots and custom homes give Gilbertown its refined country character."
Most homes here are single-family residences built from the late 1990s through the 2000s, with a strong emphasis on custom layouts and practical extras. Vaulted ceilings, granite kitchens, fireplaces, bonus rooms, sunrooms, screened porches, and finished basements appear often enough to feel characteristic rather than incidental. Garage parking is common, and several homes also add detached workshops, extra storage, or flexible outbuildings that expand the usable footprint beyond the main house. Lot sizes tend to be notably generous, and the overall impression is of a neighborhood that values privacy, craftsmanship, and space for hobbies or multi-use living.
Gilbertown’s rhythm is shaped less by clubhouse living and more by the way individual properties open onto the landscape. Fenced yards, decks, patios, and wooded backdrops create a calm residential setting with plenty of room for outdoor entertaining or quiet time at home. Some properties sit near a creek, and one listing even references a private lake, adding a subtle natural dimension to the community. Trails and outdoor recreation are part of the appeal as well, with the Rails to Trails / Thermal Belt Rail Trail frequently mentioned nearby. The overall mood is established and low-key, with the convenience of town services close enough to keep daily errands simple.
"It blends country breathing room with easy access to town conveniences."
Gilbertown sits near downtown Rutherfordton, with listings describing it as just minutes away and also close to the town’s shopping, restaurants, grocery stores, and healthcare. Public remarks point to quick access to the Rails to Trails walking and biking trail, Thermal Belt Rail Trail, and regional destinations such as Rutherford Regional Medical Center, Rutherford County Airport, Tryon International Equestrian Center, Hwy 221, Hwy 64, and I-74. The community is also described as a short drive from the broader Rutherfordton area and the surrounding foothills corridor. School assignments are not specified in the listing set provided, though RS Central High School and RS Middle School are referenced in one recent sale, underscoring the community’s connection to Rutherfordton’s school network.
Talk to a local agent about homes in Gilbertown, Rutherfordton
Communities similar to Gilbertown
2.8 mi Wilkins Forest, Rutherfordton
2 active · $301,450
1.8 mi Ruth Ridge, Rutherfordton
2 active · $405,000
2.0 mi Westgate, Rutherfordton
2 active · $34,000
5.1 mi Emerald Lake, Rutherfordton
2 active · $380,000
5.1 mi Willow Lakes, Rutherfordton
2 active · $242,450
6.2 mi River Road Farms, Rutherfordton
2 active · $407,450
35 recently sold in Gilbertown, Rutherfordton
| Property | Sold | List Price | DOM | Size | List $/SF |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| | Apr 24 2026 | $559,900 | 39 | 3,640 sq ft | $154 |
| | Mar 25 2026 | $319,900 | 33 | 2,116 sq ft | $151 |
| | Feb 9 2026 | $37,900 | 248 | — | — |
| | Feb 3 2026 | $599,900 | 232 | 4,022 sq ft | $149 |
| | Jul 31 2025 | $62,000 | 314 | — | — |
| | May 7 2025 | $20,000 | 308 | — | — |
| | Mar 21 2025 | $1,200,000 | 275 | 7,163 sq ft | $168 |
| | Sep 10 2024 | $675,000 | 74 | 3,637 sq ft | $186 |
| | Jul 17 2023 | $45,000 | 284 | — | — |
| | Sep 29 2022 | $324,900 | 144 | 1,921 sq ft | $169 |
| | Sep 28 2022 | $43,000 | 30 | — | — |
| | Jul 8 2022 | $460,000 | 53 | 3,382 sq ft | $136 |
| | Jul 1 2022 | $599,900 | 81 | 3,591 sq ft | $167 |
| | May 16 2022 | $498,000 | 49 | 2,360 sq ft | $211 |
| | May 6 2022 | $500,000 | 78 | 3,637 sq ft | $137 |
| | Apr 8 2022 | $445,000 | 126 | 2,565 sq ft | $173 |
| | Mar 21 2022 | $499,000 | 221 | 3,576 sq ft | $140 |
| | Feb 25 2022 | $49,000 | 147 | — | — |
| | Oct 27 2021 | $19,000 | 37 | — | — |
| | Mar 12 2021 | $295,000 | 62 | 2,159 sq ft | $137 |
| | Feb 9 2021 | $405,000 | 32 | 2,378 sq ft | $170 |
| | Dec 2 2020 | $449,000 | 107 | 4,103 sq ft | $109 |
| | Jul 21 2020 | $459,900 | 76 | 4,904 sq ft | $94 |
| | Feb 19 2020 | $325,000 | 107 | 2,118 sq ft | $153 |
| | Dec 13 2019 | $375,000 | 269 | 3,640 sq ft | $103 |
| | Dec 28 2018 | $269,900 | 178 | 3,382 sq ft | $80 |
| | Oct 12 2018 | $250,000 | 191 | 2,123 sq ft | $118 |
| | Jun 12 2018 | $275,000 | 64 | 2,222 sq ft | $124 |
| | May 22 2018 | $349,000 | 63 | 3,586 sq ft | $97 |
| | Nov 27 2017 | $299,900 | 83 | 2,118 sq ft | $142 |
| | Oct 17 2016 | $290,000 | 51 | 2,118 sq ft | $137 |
| | Jul 15 2016 | $270,000 | 87 | 2,050 sq ft | $132 |
| | Apr 7 2016 | $169,900 | 93 | 1,932 sq ft | $88 |
| | Oct 24 2014 | $209,900 | 940 | 2,106 sq ft | $100 |
| | Apr 15 2014 | $209,900 | 99 | 2,178 sq ft | $96 |
Aggregated from MLS listing history for Gilbertown, Rutherfordton
The Gilbertown real estate market shows buyer's market conditions. Homes typically sell within 90 days. With 2 active listings and 5 homes sold in the past year, buyers have more negotiating power and time to decide.
Save the homes you love
You've been exploring quite a few listings. Create a free account to save your favorites, follow communities, and get an alert the moment a new home hits the market.
Create your free account →Creating an account links your browsing on this site to it, so your saved homes and alerts can follow you. No spam — unsubscribe anytime.