Skip to main content

Active & Pending Listings

Buffalo Heights Homes Near Moss Lake in Shelby, NC

Buffalo Heights has a lake-adjacent, low-key character that feels rooted in space, scenery, and custom homes rather than repetition.

Listing summary: 1 Active1 Pending13 Recently Sold

Median $410,900Middle
View sold listings

Community Highlights

  • Lake-adjacent setting
  • Generous lot sizes
  • Custom home features
  • Garage and basement options
Moss Lake proximityGarageBasementLarge lots

Amenities & Lifestyle

Water Access

Moss Lake setting with some waterfront homes, docks, boat ramps, and lake views

Architecture & Style

Type
Single Family
Built
1983–2025
71% Garage41% Basement35% Waterfront
  • Open-concept layouts
  • Garages
  • Finished basements
  • Porches and patios
  • Large lots
  • Granite counters
  • Fireplaces

Location & Proximity

Piedmont region, western North Carolina

Clt Airport
less than 40 min
Us 74 Access
quick access
Moss LakeCharlotteinterstate travelCLT Airport

Nearby Schools

Elementary
Unspecified
Middle
Shelby
High
Shelby

About Buffalo Heights

AI-assisted overview based on MLS listing data for Buffalo Heights, Shelby

First Impressions

Buffalo Heights has a lake-adjacent, low-key character that feels rooted in space, scenery, and custom homes rather than repetition. The streets around Dogwood Trail, Holly Lane, Borders Road, and Stoneview Circle show a mix of established homes and newer construction, with lots that give each property room to breathe. Moss Lake is the defining backdrop here, and many of the listings lean into that setting with porches, big windows, and outdoor living areas.

"A lake-side setting with room to spread out and homes that make the most of the view."

Home Styles & Community Feel

This is a single-family neighborhood with a noticeable range in age and presentation, from early-1980s homes to brand-new builds. Several properties feature finished basements, and garage space appears often, including two-car layouts and workshop-ready lower levels. You will also find thoughtful upgrades such as granite counters, gas fireplaces, screened porches, sunrooms, and open-concept living areas. Lot sizes are a meaningful part of the appeal, with many homes sitting on generous parcels that support privacy, gardens, and outdoor gathering space.

The overall feel is custom and individualized. Some homes are polished and move-in ready, while others offer a chance to update and personalize. Waterfront properties add another layer, with docks, boat access, and gentle slopes to the water showing up in the more premium offerings.

Amenities & Daily Rhythm

Moss Lake shapes the rhythm of daily life here. It is the kind of setting where porches, patios, and covered outdoor spaces matter, and where the landscape itself becomes part of the living experience. Waterfront homes bring private docks, boat ramps, and broad views, while inland lots still benefit from the same natural surroundings and open feel. The area reads as relaxed and spacious, with nature close at hand and enough room for practical features like workshops, bonus rooms, and extra storage.

"The appeal here is equal parts lake setting, usable land, and homes built for everyday comfort."

Location & Schools

Buffalo Heights sits on Shelby’s Moss Lake side, with easy access to US-74 mentioned in nearby remarks and quick connections to interstate travel. One listing notes less than 40 minutes to CLT Airport, which gives the area a broader regional reach. The community is also described as convenient to Charlotte or interstate travel, placing it within a practical corridor for regional commuting and errands.

School information is straightforward: Shelby Middle School and Shelby High School are the commonly referenced schools, while the elementary assignment is listed as unspecified. For day-to-day needs, the neighborhood’s location near Moss Lake keeps it close to outdoor recreation and the broader Shelby area, while the main draw remains the balance of water, land, and access.

Questions about Buffalo Heights?

Talk to a local agent about homes in Buffalo Heights, Shelby

Get in contact now

864-757-4000

Palmetto Park Realty Team

Nearby Communities

Communities similar to Buffalo Heights

Recently Sold in Buffalo Heights 13 recently sold in Buffalo Heights, Shelby with dates and property details

Recently Sold

13 recently sold in Buffalo Heights, Shelby

Property Sold List Price DOM Size List $/SF
2200 Holly Lane sold home in Shelby, SC 2200 Holly Lane Apr 8 2026 $32,000 337
2060 Stoneview Circle sold home in Shelby, SC 2060 Stoneview Circle 3 bd · 3 ba Nov 13 2025 $625,000 52 2,416 sq ft $259
2201 Holly Lane sold home in Shelby, SC 2201 Holly Lane 3 bd · 2 ba Nov 4 2025 $419,900 237 3,017 sq ft $139
2013 Dogwood Trail sold home in Shelby, SC 2013 Dogwood Trail Aug 7 2025 $49,900 52
2021 Dogwood Trail sold home in Shelby, SC 2021 Dogwood Trail Dec 11 2024 $69,000 94
807 Borders Road sold home in Shelby, SC 807 Borders Road 3 bd · 3 ba Oct 31 2023 $610,000 48 3,398 sq ft $180
2213 Holly Lane sold home in Shelby, SC 2213 Holly Lane 4 bd · 2 ba Sep 14 2023 $438,500 41 2,200 sq ft $199
2017 Dogwood Trail sold home in Shelby, SC 2017 Dogwood Trail May 23 2023 $13,000 476
810 Borders Road sold home in Shelby, SC 810 Borders Road 2 bd · 2 ba Mar 30 2023 $519,900 36 2,371 sq ft $219
810 Borders Road sold home in Shelby, SC 810 Borders Road 2 bd · 2 ba Mar 3 2022 $450,000 204 2,485 sq ft $181
103 Thisa Way sold home in Shelby, SC 103 Thisa Way 3 bd · 3 ba Mar 1 2022 $459,000 193 2,535 sq ft $181
2300 Peninsula Avenue sold home in Shelby, SC 2300 Peninsula Avenue 3 bd · 3 ba Dec 23 2019 $389,900 241 2,518 sq ft $155
2008 Dogwood Trail sold home in Shelby, SC 2008 Dogwood Trail 4 bd · 3 ba Jun 25 2019 $299,999 98 2,346 sq ft $128

Market Statistics

Aggregated from MLS listing history for Buffalo Heights, Shelby

The Buffalo Heights real estate market shows buyer's market conditions. Homes typically sell within 98 days. With 2 active listings and 4 homes sold in the past year, buyers have more negotiating power and time to decide.

Pricing

Median Price
$410,900
Average Price
$410,900
$/Sq.Ft (Q1)
$140
1-Yr Price Trend
+250.0%

Property Details

Avg Bedrooms
3.0
Avg Bathrooms
2.6
Avg Lot Size
0.52 acres

Market Activity

Active Listings
2
Sold Last Year
4
Median Days to Sell
98 days

Community Info

Median Year Built
1989
New Construction
9%

Recently Off Market Properties

Listings taken off the market in the past year in Buffalo Heights, Shelby

2 properties
Looking for similar properties?

These homes are no longer available, but they show recent pricing and listing activity in Buffalo Heights. Our agents can help you watch for new listings in this area.

Contact an agent