Poinsettia Homes for Sale | Olympic-size Community Pool

Community Highlights

Poinsettia stands as one of Simpsonville's most walkable established neighborhoods, where residents enjoy freedom from HOA restrictions while living just a 6-to-15-minute walk from the shops, restaurants, and ice cream parlors of historic Downtown Simpsonville. Built primarily between 1965 and 2010, this all-brick community features mature landscaping on generously sized lots averaging over half an acre.

"Walk to Downtown Simpsonville destinations like The Slice, The Ice Cream Station, Vaughn's Food Hall, and Sidewall Pizza—or take your golf cart."

The neighborhood's defining characteristic is its rare combination of established charm and modern convenience. Most homes have undergone extensive renovations in recent years, with sellers consistently noting updates including new kitchens with quartz countertops, luxury vinyl plank flooring, renovated bathrooms, and newer roofs and HVAC systems—all while preserving original features like hardwood floors and brick fireplaces.

Amenities & Lifestyle

The community operates an optional pool membership through the Poinsettia Community Club, featuring a recently renovated Olympic-size swimming pool that serves as home to a competitive SAIL swim team and local high school swim teams. Despite having no mandatory HOA, this voluntary membership model creates a tight-knit community atmosphere with organized swim events and neighborhood gatherings.

"Recently renovated Olympic-size pool serves as home to the SAIL swim team and hosts local high school competitive swimming."

Located directly across from the newly constructed Simpsonville City Park, residents enjoy immediate access to pickleball courts, tennis courts, basketball courts, a dog park, pavilions, and walking trails. The world-class Heritage Park sits just 2.5 miles away, offering multiple ball fields, scenic walking paths, and the well-known outdoor amphitheater. The Swamp Rabbit Trail and CCHB Center are both within easy reach.

Architecture & Setting

All-brick ranch homes dominate the streetscape, with most offering single-story living on half-acre or larger lots (ranging from 0.25 to 2 acres). Common architectural features include brick fireplaces (both wood-burning and gas log), screened-in porches, covered front porches, hardwood floors, and two-car garages. Homes typically range from 1,800 to 3,000+ square feet with 3-4 bedrooms and 2-3.5 bathrooms.

The neighborhood's mature tree canopy and established landscaping create a peaceful, private setting despite the prime location. Many properties feature level, fully fenced yards with brick patios, storage outbuildings, and extensive gardens. Split-level and two-story configurations exist but represent the minority, with ranch-style single-level living being the predominant choice.

Location & Schools

Poinsettia sits in the heart of Simpsonville with exceptionally convenient access—just minutes from I-385, approximately 18 minutes to Downtown Greenville, 17 minutes to GSP International Airport, and immediate access to Fairview Road shopping and dining. Students attend Simpsonville Elementary, Bryson Middle School, and Hillcrest High School, with all three schools consistently mentioned positively in listing remarks.

Market Overview

With 14 homes sold in the past year and just 3 active listings, Poinsettia maintains limited inventory status. Recent sales have ranged from $365,000 to $645,000, with the strongest activity in the $385,000-$475,000 range. Premium properties on S Almond Drive and Hillpine Drive—particularly those with larger lots, saltwater pools, or extensive renovations—command prices approaching or exceeding $500,000. Average days on market of 28 days reflects steady demand for this established location.